Why Occupational Therapists Should Recommend Monitored Over Non-Monitored Alarms

Occupational therapists hold a quiet but powerful position in the lives of older Australians. When you recommend a personal alarm to a client, your judgement carries weight. Families listen. Clients trust the advice. The right device, recommended at the right time, can be the difference between someone continuing to live well at home and an avoidable hospital admission.

The market for personal alarms has become noisier in recent years, and the line between professionally monitored services and non-monitored alternatives has blurred. The distinction matters more than it might first appear.

Where the Market Gets Confusing

On the shelf, a non-monitored alarm can look almost identical to a professionally monitored one. Same pendant, same button, similar marketing copy. The key difference is what happens after the button is pressed.

A non-monitored alarm dials a pre-programmed list of family or friends. If no one answers, the call cycles to the next number. If the client has fallen, is confused, or cannot speak clearly, there is no professional on the other end to assess the situation, no trained operator to triage, and no infrastructure designed to ensure help is actually dispatched.

A professionally monitored alarm, by contrast, connects directly to a 24/7 response centre staffed by trained operators. They speak to the client, assess what is happening, contact emergency services or nominated contacts as appropriate, and stay in touch until help arrives.

The complication is that some providers have added a “monitored option” to products that were originally designed for self-monitoring. That label can sound the same as the service a PERSL member delivers, but it often isn’t. The certification of the monitoring centre, the protocols staff follow, and the standard the service is built to all vary significantly. For your client, the device might look identical. The service behind it can be entirely different.

You Can Receive Ongoing Updates From a Monitored Service

This is one of the most underappreciated clinical advantages of professional monitoring. When your client uses a monitored alarm from a PERSL member, the monitoring centre keeps a structured record of every activation. Date, time, nature of the event, response taken, who was contacted, and outcome.

As the recommending OT, you can request these reports (with the client’s consent) and use them to inform your ongoing care planning. Are activations becoming more frequent? Are falls happening at the same time of day? Is the client pressing the button accidentally, suggesting a need for re-education or a different style of device?

With a self-monitored alarm, none of this exists. There is no record beyond what the family happens to remember and share with you. The clinical feedback loop is broken before it begins.

Redundancy, Resiliency, and the Service Wrapped Around the Product

What you are really recommending when you choose a monitored alarm is not a device. It is an entire service. The pendant or wristband is simply the touchpoint.

Behind it sits redundant communication infrastructure, backup power, trained operators, escalation protocols, and quality systems designed to ensure that a button press translates into the right outcome every single time. PERSL members are required to meet the AS 4607 Australian Standard for personal emergency response systems. This is the specific Australian standard for this category of service, and it is the credential to look for.

A point worth flagging here: ISO 9001 certification on its own is not the same thing as meeting AS 4607. ISO 9001 is a general quality management standard that applies to almost any business in any industry. It is a useful baseline, but it says nothing specific about how a personal emergency response service is designed, staffed, or escalated. Likewise, monitoring centre grading systems typically describe the physical resilience of the facility rather than the response protocols inside it. A provider can hold ISO 9001 or a high facility grade and still not meet AS 4607. For a clinically defensible recommendation, AS 4607 is the floor.

A self-monitored alarm, of course, offers none of this. If the family member listed as the first contact is in a meeting, on a flight, or simply has their phone on silent, the system has failed in the moment it was needed most. For a clinically vulnerable client, that gap is unacceptable.

Supporting Clients Through Support at Home and NDIS

For OTs working within Support at Home or under NDIS plans, a monitored alarm is a credible, evidence-aligned recommendation that fits squarely within reasonable and necessary supports. It is a low-cost intervention with strong protective value, particularly for clients with a history of falls, cognitive change, social isolation, or chronic conditions.

A monitored alarm can also extend the reach of the care team. Operators are not a substitute for clinical care, but they are an additional set of eyes and ears in the home, providing prompt response in the moments between scheduled visits and supports. For clients trying to remain at home through Support at Home funding, that bridge matters.

A Note on Coverage

It is worth flagging that personal alarms require adequate mobile network coverage to function. They do not work in areas with patchy or no mobile reception. For clients in rural or remote locations, satellite-enabled alarms are an alternative, though not every PERSL member offers them. It is worth confirming coverage and device suitability with the individual provider when matching a device to a client’s home environment.

What to Look For When Recommending

When you make a recommendation, the questions worth asking the provider include:

  • Are you a PERSL member?
  • Do you meet AS 4607? (ISO 9001 or facility grading on its own is not a substitute.)
  • Is your monitoring centre based in Australia and staffed 24/7?
  • What reporting can you provide to clinicians involved in the client’s care?
  • What is your average response time?
  • Does the device suit my client’s environment, including mobile coverage at their address?

Recommending a monitored alarm from a PERSL member is not just a safer choice for your client. It is a clinically defensible one, backed by national standards, structured reporting, and a service designed for the moments that matter most. Peace of mind, for your client and their family, really is just a button-press away.

To find an accredited PERSL member who can support your clients, visit persl.com.au/about-us.